A Winning Combination

What is a cotenancy clause in retail leases?

On Behalf of | May 7, 2025 | Real Estate Law |

A cotenancy clause is a provision in commercial leases, especially in shopping centers or malls, that helps tenants maintain a profitable business. It ensures that certain conditions must be met for the lease to remain valid, impacting both tenants and landlords. This clause is often used to create a balanced and fair environment where both parties can thrive.

What does a cotenancy clause require?

A cotenancy clause often requires that key tenants stay in the shopping center or retail space for the lease to remain valid. For instance, a tenant may be able to reduce rent or terminate the lease if anchor tenants, such as large department stores, leave. These tenants are crucial to attracting foot traffic, and their absence could lead to a significant decline in sales. The clause may also address how many tenants need to remain or which types of businesses must be present.

Benefits for tenants

A cotenancy clause offers tenants financial protection and flexibility. If key tenants leave, the retailer may not want to stay in a less popular shopping center. The clause can reduce rent or allow tenants to exit the lease without penalties, particularly if the area loses customer appeal. This clause is particularly useful in large shopping centers that rely on heavy foot traffic. With this clause in place, tenants can mitigate risks associated with drastic changes to the shopping center’s dynamic.

Benefits for landlords

Commercial real estate landlords must negotiate cotenancy clauses carefully to avoid losing income. These clauses protect landlords from losing tenants due to the departure of anchor tenants. They may offer rent reductions or other benefits to maintain tenant occupancy and stability. By understanding and managing these clauses, landlords can keep a balanced mix of tenants and safeguard their long-term rental income.

Cotenancy clauses are essential in retail leases, especially in shopping centers, where the success of one tenant affects others. They offer flexibility to tenants, allowing them to adjust to changes in the tenant mix. Landlords must balance these provisions to maintain property value and ensure tenant retention.